Auditors’ Materiality Judgments

eva litlabø_NHH interiør_trude brun wilhelmsen
Which errors in a company’s financial statements are significant enough to influence investors’ decisions? In her doctoral thesis, Eva Litlabø has examined how auditors make such assessments in both financial and sustainability reporting. She will defend her thesis at NHH on 3 December. Photo: Trude Brun Wilhelmsen
PhD Defense

16 November 2026 08:14

Auditors’ Materiality Judgments

On Thursdayt 3 December Eva Litlabø will hold a trial lecture on a prescribed topic and defend her thesis for the PhD degree at NHH.

Title of the thesis: 

 «Materiality in Auditing and Assurance Services».

Summary: 

Materiality judgments are central to determining the scope of auditors’ work and evaluating identified misstatements. Misstatements are considered material if they could influence the decisions of users of corporate reporting.

Eva Litlabø’s doctoral thesis provides new insights into auditors’ materiality judgments through three papers.

The first paper, published in Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, reviews research on auditors’ materiality judgments from 2005 to 2025. Among the main conclusions, the review finds that auditors commonly use pre-tax income as the basis for setting materiality, although they often account for other factors. The review also finds that investors do not have a good understanding of the materiality concept, and that materiality thresholds are associated with audit quality.

The second paper draws on interviews to investigate Norwegian audit firms’ sustainability assurance practices and auditors’ materiality judgments. Sustainability reports cover a wide range of qualitative and quantitative information, posing new challenges for audit firms and requiring auditors to exercise professional judgment. Materiality judgments in this context draw on both sustainability-specific knowledge and experience gained from financial statement audits.

The third paper uses an experiment with 130 auditors to investigate whether auditors’ materiality judgments are influenced by the geographical distance to an environmental incident and by how affected stakeholders are portrayed in the information available to the auditor. The results provide no evidence that either factor influences auditors’ materiality judgments, possibly reflecting auditors’ professionalism.

Together, the three papers advance the understanding of auditors’ materiality judgments across auditing and assurance contexts.

Prescribed topic for the trial lecture: 

Tba 

Trial lecture and defense:  

Aud N. Trial lecture starts 14:00 and defense 15:30 

Supervisors:  

Professor emeritus Aasmund Eilifsen (main supervisor), Department of Accounting, Auditing and Law 

Associated Professor and head of Department Finn Kinserdal, Department of Accounting, Auditing and Law 

Professor Natalia Kochetova, Saint Mary's University (and NHH) and professor emeritus NHH, William Messier 

Members of the evaluation committee: 

Associated Professor Ulf Mohrmann (chair of the committee), Department of Accounting, Auditing and Law 

Professor Tamara Lambert, University of Manchester 

Professor Brant Christensen, Brigham Young University