The Value of Disagreement

Background and purpose

Academic freedom and open intellectual disagreement are fundamental to the role of universities and higher education institutions. Researchers must be free to challenge established ideas, critically engage with each other’s research, and participate actively in public debate – including when the issues are controversial and disagreements are substantial.

At the same time, strong academic freedom depends on a healthy culture of debate. There must be room for robust academic criticism, but also an awareness of how we engage with those we disagree with and how our own contributions may affect others’ willingness and ability to participate. This is particularly important in an academic environment characterised by differences in experience, position and academic authority.

NHH therefore wishes to organise a conference on academic freedom, responsibility and the culture of academic debate. A particular aim is to discuss how we can encourage younger researchers to participate in academic and public debate, while fostering a culture that welcomes genuine intellectual disagreement.

The conference will focus less on defining the legal boundaries of freedom of expression and more on how we can create a culture with greater openness, more substantive disagreement and a wider range of voices.

Programme

12:15–12:30
Why does NHH need a strong culture of academic debate?

Opening remarks by Rector Helge Thorbjørnsen

Why disagreement matters in academia – and why a strong culture of debate is important for research, education and NHH’s role in society.

12:30–13:00
Academic freedom – how free should it be?

Anine Kierulf, Professor, University of Oslo

Keynote on academic freedom and responsibility, drawing on the work of the Norwegian Commission on Academic Freedom of Expression (NOU 2022:2).

Introduction: Kurt Brekke

13:00–13:15
Why should researchers engage in public debate?

Alexander Cappelen, Professor, NHH

A talk about research communication and participation in public debate with time for Q&A.

13:15–13:30
“Finding your voice” – young & international researchers in the public debate

Ole Andreas Næss and Gabriel Fuentes, Associate professors, NHH

Reflections reflect on their experiences of participating in public debate – what motivates them, what they have learned, and what may encourage younger researchers to take part.

13:30–13:45
Academia through the eyes of the media

Eirin Eikefjord, Political Editor, Bergens Tidende

Conversation with Geir Mikalsen

13:45–14:15
Panel discussion:
What does a healthy culture of public debate look like in academia?

Participants: Katrine Løken (moderator)

  • Anine Kierulf
  • Alexander Cappelen
  • Eirin Eikefjord
  • Gabriel Moises Fuentes
  • Ole Andreas Næss

Concluding remarks: Helge Thorbjørnsen